Sarah's Thoughts
No TV, No Car Keys and … You’re Having This Baby!
As most people already know, Senator Obama made this lovely statement in Pennsylvania:
“Look, I got two daughters — 9 years old and 6 years old. I am going to teach them first about values and morals, but if they make a mistake, I don’t want them punished with a baby. I don’t want them punished with an STD at age 16, so it doesn’t make sense to not give them information.”
First, let me begin by stating that I am not an absolutist on the abortion issue. I know that it is a painful and complicated decision and there are instances in which this horrible action must be considered.
Now, to the point of my post …
Like the fine senator, I do believe that words matter. I don’t understand how someone can casually use “punish” and “baby” in the same sentence. A punishment is what a teenager deserves if she breaks curfew or gets caught drinking (I already have a list of creative punishments saved up for when Catherine inevitably irritates me in high school). A created life is not “punishment” for having sex. The baby will not exit the womb waving a scolding finger at her teenage mother. When Obama used the words “baby” and “punish” together, it stung. And, I know I am not alone in feeling this way.
I do believe in teaching teenagers about sex and how to protect themselves. I am not of the camp that believes showing a young person a condom is the same as putting it on him and closing his bedroom door while his girlfriend visits. (I had a friend in high school whose mother would hand her condoms after school so that she could have sex with her boyfriend. She even waved at them when they departed to the bedroom and said, “Have fun!”. Why I was there watching soaps with her mother, I do not recall.) So, I agree with Senator Obama when he asserts that our high school students need to be given information.
However, once two people decide to engage in an adult activity, they need to take on the adult responsibility that might result from that lovely union in the back of his ‘94 Accord (or the hotel on prom night or the back of the physics classroom). And, no, I don’t think the adult decision is just to say, “Let’s get rid of it because we don’t deserve to be ‘punished’ for our irresponsible actions.” Of course, we are teaching young people these days that they shouldn’t be held accountable for any of their decisions (Fall asleep in class? Sue the teacher! Wreck your new car? Get your parents to buy you a new one!), so why should sex be any different?
I believe that Barack Obama’s view of unwanted pregnancies as “punishments” is disturbing. Come on, Obama! Just think of the children as more people to sweet talk into your government dependence programs. Get them while they are young and pliable and your condescending, arrogant speeches will seem as natural as mother’s milk.









April 2nd, 2008 at 1:32 pm
I guess its a cultural thing…I thought it was well established that having a baby as a teenager isn’t exactly a benchmark in success in life.
April 2nd, 2008 at 1:41 pm
Sean — I couldn’t agree more. Where did I state otherwise? I never wrote that we should pin ribbons on teenagers who have babies. Go ahead and give one strike to the kid born to a teenage mommy.
I just find Obama’s attitude towards the “mistake” of getting pregnant, like it’s equivalent to forgetting to take out the trash or coming home without putting gas in the car, quite unappealing.
April 2nd, 2008 at 6:43 pm
I just find Obama’s attitude towards the “mistake” of getting pregnant, like it’s equivalent to forgetting to take out the trash or coming home without putting gas in the car, quite unappealing.
If he felt that way, he wouldn’t have emphasized the need for Sex-Ed so that teenagers don’t make that mistake.
He probably should’ve chosen his words more carefully, but ultimately, he was saying that we need to teach kids about safe sex so they aren’t (how to put this in PC terms) dealing with the consequences of their youthful decisions for the rest of their life.
April 3rd, 2008 at 7:03 am
Sean…. We do deal with the consequences of “All” of our decisions for the rest of our lives, good or bad.
Obama referred to this situation as “Punishment”. He could have said “Consequences” and everyone would have aggreed with him, but he didn’t.
April 3rd, 2008 at 9:41 am
Yes, I agree that he should parse his words more carefully.